Since 2014, in France, Restorative Justice has offered victims and perpetrators of offences the opportunity to dialogue through secure systems, supervised by professionals and volunteers such as Judith, Fanny or Michel. Nassim, Issa, and Thomas, sentenced for theft with violence, Gregoire, Nawelle and Sabine, victims of home jacking, robbery and purse snatching. Also Chloe, victim of incestuous rape, all engage in measures of Restorative Justice. On their journey, there is anger and hope, silence and words, alliances and heartbreaks, awareness and regained confidence. And at the end of the road, sometimes, reparation.
3.5 题材新颖,让观众了解了一个不曾接触过的新概念——“恢复性司法”,本片可能更倾向于介绍这一社会团体的工作成果的宣传和展示片,整体总觉有些理想化、简单化,因为如果是很严重的伤害,让施害者和受害者别说谅解,就是坐在一起面对面心平气和讲话显然都很难,居然最后能把手言欢,这种情形即使完全客观真实,可能只能适用于比如三年以下轻罪的受害者吧;然而不得不承认法国人在社会治理、犯罪矫治和文明发展水平的程度之高、思考之深,无论如何应该支持这类难度极高的社会问题根治的探索与尝试;以及又见阿黛尔里的阿黛尔,好亲切 #SFM
虽然有点白人无脑圣母心的感觉,但是看的过程还挺感动的
3971 Time:2024-3-3
有时候会感慨其他国家的司法制度竟然能细化到如此地步,探讨不同形式的可能性。如果为被害者的创伤心境和加害者的内心剖析提供一个安全环境,两者对谈,是否会有助于愈合创伤,减少犯罪?电影两条线的设置展现了“恢复性司法”所面对状况的复杂性,但结果的单一性让主题探讨的深度弱了许多。电影感觉更像读了一篇关于“恢复性司法”的实践论文,其本身的社会意义更大
探索“恢复性司法”,将会比监狱更有意义吗?
Copyright © 2008-2020 网站地图